A pension fund invests over 18 million euros in a hotel management company, only to receive no annual accounts, no replies and a claim for damages in response to requests for information. On 16 July 2026, the Enterprise Chamber refused to let the matter rest there.
The case
Grand Metropolitan Hotels Holding B.V. (Grand Met) was incorporated on 16 September 2022 by Kingstone Capital Holding Limited, a company incorporated under the laws of the United Arab Emirates. Grand Met presents itself as the rights holder to various hospitality concepts for luxury hotels and resorts.
Between its incorporation and April 2024, Kingstone acquired a total of over 200 million shares in Grand Met in seven share issues, each time in return for a contribution in kind. In the first and immediately largest issue, in September 2022, Kingstone contributed shares in a company whose principal asset consisted of rights to AI software (Genisys AI), valued at 100 million euros. That valuation was based on a report commissioned by Kingstone itself, with an explicit disclaimer stating that the author accepts no responsibility for the accuracy of any information contained in the report. Further share issues in 2023 and 2024 followed the same pattern: the contribution of shares in group companies, each time valued at tens of millions, without independent verification.
Versorgungswerk der Zahnärztekammer Berlin KdöR (VZB), a public-law pension fund for dentists in the Berlin region, built up a 25.1 per cent stake in Grand Met in four tranches between August 2023 and April 2024. VZB paid a total of 18,031,433.60 euros to Kingstone for this. Goltstein Capital Beteiligungen GmbH acquired 4.6 per cent. Kingstone retained 70.3 per cent.
In early 2025, concerns arose within VZB regarding the investment policy. A member of its Representative Assembly put detailed questions to Grand Met in thirteen comprehensive letters. These remained largely unanswered. On 4 December 2025, Grand Met’s director responded to a repeat request for annual accounts not with the requested documents, but with a notice of a claim for damages and the statement that VZB had had "more than forfeited" its rights.
On 4 March 2026, VZB wrote down the value of its stake in Grand Met from 18 million to zero. The explanation for this write-down read: "no contact, no documents, suspicion of fraud."
On 23 December 2025, VZB submitted a request for an inquiry to the Enterprise Chamber.
The legal issue
The Enterprise Chamber had to assess whether there were valid grounds for doubting the soundness of Grand Met’s policy and conduct within the meaning of Article 2:350 of the Dutch Civil Code, and whether the company’s situation necessitated the adoption of immediate measures.
Within this context, the assessment focused on four issues: (1) did Kingstone actually comply with the payment obligation under Section 2:191(1) of the Dutch Civil Code in connection with the share issues; (2) did Grand Met breach its disclosure obligations towards VZB as a minority shareholder under Section 2:8 of the Dutch Civil Code; (3) is the composition of the management board and supervisory board problematic in the light of the required checks and balances; and (4) are the financial reporting and accounts in order?
Grand Met defended itself by arguing that there was no deadlock within its governing bodies, that it had provided all available information, and that the unrest was solely attributable to VZB’s new management, which had undermined a previously successful collaboration.
The ruling
The Enterprise Chamber finds that, on each of the four points, there are valid grounds for doubting the soundness of the policy.
Obligation to pay up
Pursuant to Section 2:191(1) of the Dutch Civil Code, the nominal amount must be paid up upon the acquisition of a share. Contributions in kind must be valued according to economic criteria (Article 2:191b of the Dutch Civil Code) and the company must draw up a description which is made available for inspection by shareholders (Article 2:204b of the Dutch Civil Code). With regard to the first issue (100 million, Genisys AI), the Enterprise Chamber finds that the valuation is based on a report commissioned not by Grand Met but by Kingstone, that the author expressly disclaims any responsibility for its accuracy, and that, at the hearing, it was not possible to explain, even approximately, how much turnover and profit are generated by the software, which customers use it, and what functionalities the product has. Nevertheless, no write-down was made in the 2022/23 and 2024 annual accounts. The same applies to the other share issues (which together also amounted to approximately 100 million): what the contributed companies do and on what basis the valuations were made has remained entirely unclear. Grand Met did not carry out any due diligence. The Enterprise Chamber concludes from this that it is unclear whether Kingstone complied with the payment obligation through its contributions and that the directors failed to adequately monitor compliance with this obligation.
Governance.
In principle, every legal entity is free to organise itself as it sees fit (Supreme Court 9 July 2010, ECLI:NL:HR:2010:BM0976, ASMI; Supreme Court 20 April 2018, ECLI:NL:HR:2018:652, Boskalis/Fugro). However, the Enterprise Chamber has found that the arrangement whereby two directors form the management board whilst the spouse of one of them acts as a supervisory director is "certainly not optimal from the point of view of checks and balances". Furthermore, where very substantial transactions are carried out with a legal entity of which one of those same persons is the sole director and major shareholder, they are subject to an enhanced duty of care towards minority shareholders (cf. Supreme Court 3 May 2002, ECLI:NL:HR:2002:AD9857, Zwagerman; Amsterdam Court of Appeal 22 May 2025, ECLI:NL:GHAMS:2025:2267, Steenfabriek de Rijswaard). The fact that the same supervisory director also acted as interim CFO and was nominated as a director of subsidiary companies reinforces this duty of care.
Provision of information.
From the moment VZB was no longer represented on the Supervisory Board (February 2025), Grand Met was required, on its own initiative and in response to enquiries, to ensure sufficient transparency, as follows from the principles of reasonableness and fairness under Article 2:8 of the Dutch Civil Code. Nevertheless, Grand Met systematically refused to provide the requested annual accounts and information regarding the proposed acquisition of Voile d’Or Hotels and Resorts AG. That company had been acquired by Kingstone shortly beforehand for CHF 100,000 and was subsequently to be contributed to Grand Met as a contribution in kind valued at 130 million. The ‘Opinion of Value’ attached to the contribution proposal was a report prepared by one of the parties, based entirely on information provided by Kingstone without any independent verification (cf. Amsterdam Court of Appeal 2024, ECLI:NL:GHAMS:2024:3574, Simetra). VZB was reasonably entitled to take the view that, on the basis of that report, it could not make a well-considered decision regarding a potential capital injection of 43.5 million euros.
Financial reporting.
With a subscribed capital of more than 200 million euros, Grand Met reports under the micro-regime, without consolidated financial statements. The 2022/23 and 2024 financial statements were not filed on time. Grand Met itself acknowledges that its financial records were deficient. The Enterprise Chamber finds that this, particularly against the backdrop of the large share issues, constitutes a valid ground for doubt.
The Enterprise Chamber has ordered an investigation into Grand Met’s policies and conduct over the period from its incorporation on 16 September 2022 to the present. As immediate measures, both directors are suspended and an independent director is appointed (Mr I.C.J.C. van de Klundert). The shares held by Kingstone (minus one) are transferred to a trustee to be appointed for the purposes of administration. All supervisory board members are suspended and the provisions of the articles of association relating to the supervisory board are temporarily suspended. Grand Met is ordered to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Implications for practice
This ruling demonstrates how rapidly the right to conduct an inquiry can escalate when three indicators are present simultaneously: contributions in kind towards shares without an independent valuation, a governance structure in which supervisory board members and directors are intertwined through family ties, and a systematic refusal to provide information to a minority shareholder. The Enterprise Chamber therefore intervenes on all three fronts simultaneously.
Particularly noteworthy is the ruling regarding the Opinion of Value in the Voile d’Or transaction. A valuation report based entirely on figures supplied by the client, without any independent verification, is not sufficient as a basis for a well-considered investment decision by a minority shareholder. This standard also applies to situations outside the inquiry procedure: anyone presenting a report as a majority shareholder or director in connection with a share issue or takeover will have to be able to demonstrate that the report is genuinely independent and verifiable.
The combination of roles (a supervisory director acting as interim CFO, a spouse acting as supervisor of the director) is not automatically declared unlawful, but it does give rise to an increased duty of care. This provides a practical guideline: family law relationships within a company structure are not prohibited in themselves, but require extra, documented due diligence in any decision where a potential conflict of interest arises.
What you can do
Are you considering an investment as a minority shareholder in a company where the majority shareholder also controls the management and supervisory bodies? In that case, the quality of valuation reports for share issues, the completeness of the financial records and the board’s willingness to provide information are not minor issues but key elements of your due diligence.
Conversely, the following applies to directors and supervisory board members operating within a structure involving family ties: document your decision-making, ensure an independent valuation for contributions in kind, and comply with your disclosure obligations towards all shareholders.
More information?
TK is happy to advise you on the design of your company structure, your position as a minority or majority shareholder, and the preparation for or defence in an inquiry procedure. Please contact Michiel or one of the other professionals from the Corporate & Commercial Litigation