Back to news overview

Corporate & Commercial Litigation

A handshake as proof: when does a verbal guarantee bind the holding company?

28 September 2026

Anyone seeking security from the parent companies behind a contractor in a construction dispute must have that security set out in writing. A handshake and five witnesses are sometimes not enough. The Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal ruled on this on 1 September 2026 in proceedings concerning a failed construction project and a settlement agreement that was never signed.

The case

In February 2022, Reno Systems B.V. entered into a building contract with Altea Holding B.V. for the extension of Altea’s business premises and the installation of insulated sandwich panels. Reno Systems failed to fulfil its obligations: the work was not carried out on time or in accordance with the agreements. The parties negotiated the termination of the building contract. A meeting was held on 15 February 2023 for this purpose, attended not only by Altea’s director and her solicitor but also by the two directors/shareholders of the holding companies behind Reno Systems: [appellant2] Beheer B.V. and Kade Beheer B.V.

Altea wanted security. Reno Systems had been checked via Creditsafe and turned out to be a shell company. Altea therefore demanded that the holding companies act as guarantors for the fulfilment of the agreements to be made. Several options were discussed: a surety, a bank guarantee, or personal co-signing. At some point, according to Altea, a handshake agreement was reached under the motto: ‘a man, a man, a word, a word’.

A written settlement agreement, containing a joint and several liability clause in Article 5, was subsequently drawn up by Altea’s solicitor and sent to Reno. That agreement was never signed. In the subsequent correspondence, Reno Systems’ solicitors repeatedly stated that there was no question of joint and several liability on the part of the holding companies and that this could not have been the intention either. Altea eventually initiated legal proceedings and obtained protective attachments. The District Court of the Northern Netherlands upheld the claims by judgment of 6 December 2023, as Reno et al. had not put forward a defence.

On appeal, Reno et al. contested only the judgment against [appellant2] Beheer and Kade Beheer. The judgments against Reno Systems itself therefore remained in force.

The legal issue

The central question was whether [appellant 2] Beheer and Kade Beheer had, during the meeting of 15 February 2023, jointly and severally undertaken to fulfil Reno Systems’ obligations under the (subsequently to be drawn up) settlement agreement. Altea bore the burden of proof regarding that assertion. In the interim judgment of 3 December 2024, the Court of Appeal ruled that neither the payment of €10,000 by Reno Systems nor the email correspondence between lawyers regarding the draft met that burden of proof. After all, Reno’s payment said nothing about the holding companies’ liability, and the emails, on the contrary, repeatedly and explicitly disavowed joint and several liability. The Court of Appeal gave Altea the opportunity to provide evidence through witnesses.

The judgement

In the final judgement of 1 September 2026, the Court of Appeal concluded that Altea had failed to meet its burden of proof, even through witness evidence.

Each party called witnesses. Altea called its director, its lawyer at the time and a person involved on its side. Reno et al. called the two directors of the holding companies and a representative of the subcontractor Remmont B.V. The statements were diametrically opposed on the crucial point: had agreement been reached during the meeting regarding a guarantee by the holding companies?

Altea’s director stated that the holding companies had agreed and that a handshake had taken place. His solicitor confirmed that he had raised the matter, that the other party had discussed it, and that Reno’s own counsel (Mr Schutte) had subsequently given his consent. The third witness for Altea confirmed that the handshake had taken place, but could no longer recall the exact wording with which the holding companies had given their consent.

The directors of the holding companies categorically denied this. They stated that guarantees by their companies had never been discussed and that Mr Schutte had not given his consent either. Remmont’s representative could hardly remember anything and was equally unable to confirm that any agreements regarding guarantees had been made.
The Court of Appeal weighed up the statements against one another and ruled that the statement by Altea’s lawyer was too vague to be decisive: he had stated that Mr Schutte had given his consent, but could not specify exactly what that consent covered. The statement by the third witness was equally insufficient, as he was unable to reproduce the decisive wording. The statements by Altea’s witnesses were countered by the denials of both directors of the holding companies. In this regard, the Court of Appeal took into account that it is not implausible that entrepreneurs would not have wished to bind their personal holding companies to an obligation whose nature and scope were insufficiently clear at that time.

The Court of Appeal quashed the joint and several judgments against [Appellant 2] Beheer and Kade Beheer. Reno Systems’ own appeal was declared inadmissible. Altea was ordered to pay the holding companies’ legal costs in the appeal proceedings: €15,188 for lawyers’ fees.

Implications for practice

This judgment illustrates how vulnerable a case becomes when security arrangements are made exclusively verbally. Even with several witnesses on one’s own side, including one’s own solicitor, it is not always possible to convince a court of appeal of the substance of what was agreed during a discussion. It is not about the handshake itself, but about whether the statements provide sufficiently convincing evidence that the other party agreed to the specific obligation which you claim was agreed.

Two aspects deserve particular attention. Firstly, the email exchange following the meeting actually worked against Altea in this case. In those emails, Reno and others explicitly distanced themselves from the joint and several liability of the holding companies. If agreement had indeed been reached during the meeting, this should have been evident in the subsequent correspondence. It was not. Secondly: the burden of proof lay with Altea. Anyone wishing to invoke a guarantee or joint and several liability on the part of a holding company must prove that claim. The fact that a draft agreement contained a joint and several liability clause was insufficient, as that agreement had not been signed and the other party had contested its content on reasonable grounds.

What you can do

If you find yourself in negotiations where you want assurance from the companies behind a contracting party, ensure that agreements regarding guarantees or joint and several liability are recorded immediately, even if the underlying agreement is not yet final. A written confirmation by email, sent immediately after the discussion and not contested, carries greater evidential value than a reconstruction based on witness accounts at a later date.

If you are on the other side as a holding company and wish to avoid being unintentionally bound by agreements made on behalf of your company, ensure that it is clear internally who is authorised to make what commitments and that commitments are only binding once they have been confirmed in writing.

Would you like more information?

TK would be happy to advise you on the structure of your contractual security arrangements, the evidential position in an ongoing dispute or the strategy for negotiating a settlement agreement. Please contact Michiel or one of the other professionals from the Corporate & Commercial Litigation.