A minority shareholder who wishes to withdraw but first wants to hear witnesses in order to assess her legal position: the Enterprise Chamber has rejected that request. The decision of 28 August 2026 clarifies when a provisional hearing of witnesses before the Enterprise Chamber is likely to succeed, and when it is not.
The case
Corvallis Navigation SARL, a Swiss company based in Geneva, acquired 25 per cent of the shares in JT Sports Holding B.V. (the Company) for €63 million in 2022 through its legal predecessor. The Company heads the GC Group, which operates in the international equestrian sports sector. [C] Trading Belgium BV (TTB) holds the majority stake: 55 per cent. The remaining shares are held by two other minority shareholders, each holding 10 per cent.
The shareholders entered into a shareholders’ agreement on 23 March 2022. This agreement grants minority shareholders more influence than is required by law. Resolutions of the general meeting always require the vote of at least one minority shareholder. For certain categories of legal acts, including the disposal of ‘material assets’ and significant changes to strategy, a higher majority requirement applies. The agreement also contains extensive provisions on disclosure and confidentiality (Art. 12 and Art. 22 respectively).
In 2023, a personal conflict arose between the UBO of Corvallis and [C], the sole shareholder of TTB and founder of the GC Group. The forecasts from 2022 fell far short of reality. In 2024, Corvallis announced its intention to sell its stake. It claimed that the Company was delaying the sale process: the Company demanded that it itself be made a party to the NDAs to be concluded with prospective buyers and that those NDAs contain a penalty clause. Corvallis refused this, entered into an NDA itself with a prospective buyer without a penalty clause and without the Company as a party, following which no information was provided.
On 12 February 2026, Corvallis lodged a petition with the Enterprise Chamber. It requested a provisional examination of witnesses pursuant to Article 196 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The aim was to establish its legal position and gather evidence for a possible application to be bought out (Article 2:343 of the Dutch Civil Code) and/or an inquiry procedure (Article 2:344 of the Dutch Civil Code). On 2 June 2026, Corvallis conditionally expanded its application to include a request for an inquiry, including interim measures. The Enterprise Chamber refused this extension on the grounds that it was contrary to the proper conduct of proceedings: the other parties and interested stakeholders would not have had sufficient opportunity to defend themselves.
The legal issue
Two questions arose. Firstly, the question of jurisdiction: does the Enterprise Chamber have the power to order a provisional examination of witnesses, given that Article 66 of the Judiciary Organisation Act (RO) does not expressly provide for this? Secondly, the substantive question: does the application meet the requirements of Articles 196 and 197 of the Code of Civil Procedure?
Pursuant to Article 196(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure, the court shall grant a request for provisional taking of evidence, unless (a) the information sought is insufficiently specified, (b) there is insufficient interest, (c) the application is contrary to the proper conduct of proceedings, (d) there is an abuse of power, or (e) other compelling reasons preclude it. The Enterprise Chamber assesses these grounds in conjunction with one another.
Corvallis wished to hear evidence on three topics: (i) the manner in which the Company organised the sale process, (ii) the treatment of minority shareholders in the so-called ‘Team Sales’ and in transactions between the Company and [C] or legal entities affiliated with him, and (iii) the actual influence of [C] on the Company’s policy.
The ruling
The Enterprise Chamber declares itself competent. Article 197(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure permits an application for the taking of provisional evidence to be made to the court which is presumed to have jurisdiction to hear the main proceedings. The Enterprise Chamber has exclusive jurisdiction over applications for withdrawal and inquiry proceedings; that jurisdiction extends to the preparation thereof. The fact that Article 66 of the Rules of Procedure does not mention the taking of provisional evidence does not alter this. The Enterprise Chamber refers to the Supreme Court judgment of 17 November 2017, ECLI:NL:HR:2017:2904.
On the merits, the Enterprise Chamber rejects the application. It reaches the same conclusion for each point of evidence: either the relevant facts are already known or the uncertainty is of a purely legal nature, so that hearing a witness would not clarify the matter.
With regard to the sale process, the Enterprise Chamber ruled that Corvallis does not have an unrestricted right to information under the shareholders’ agreement or Article 2:8 of the Dutch Civil Code. The conditions imposed by the Company regarding the data room – being a party to the NDA and a penalty clause – do not contravene the shareholders’ agreement or the principles of reasonableness and fairness. On the contrary, the Company has consistently invited consultation, offered a roadmap and put forward two prospective buyers. It is Corvallis itself that is blocking progress by categorically refusing the NDA conditions.
Regarding the transactions with [C], the Enterprise Chamber finds that the facts concerning the travel allowance (a fixed sum of €300,000 per year for many years, since adjusted) and the tacit continuation of the consultancyagreement after 25 March 2025. The dispute concerning the extension of that agreement is of a legal nature: a witness has not answered the question of whether the consent of all shareholders or the approval of the supervisory board is required. The same applies to the lease agreement for the arena in Valkenswaard: there is no dispute that the Company did not inform Corvallis in advance about the planning permission procedure; only the legal question of whether it should have done so is in dispute.
Regarding [C]’s actual influence, the Enterprise Chamber considers that Corvallis attends all meetings of the supervisory board via its own supervisory director and its litigation counsel, who acts as a board observer. It therefore already possesses a substantial knowledge base. Informal consultations between [C] and the management board are consistent with the proper performance of his duties, given his role as GC President under the shareholders’ agreement.
The conclusion is as follows: the information requested is insufficiently specified and Corvallis has an insufficient interest. The grounds for dismissal under Article 196(2)(a) and (b) of the Code of Civil Procedure apply. Corvallis is ordered to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Implications for practice
The decision confirms and tightens the test set out in Article 196(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure. A preliminary examination of witnesses is not a tool for exploratory purposes if the facts are already broadly known. Anyone wishing to hear witnesses must specify what information is missing, why a witness can provide that information, and what purpose this serves in the proceedings to be conducted.
This applies particularly strongly in shareholder disputes: a board observer who attends all supervisory board meetings can hardly claim afterwards that the course of events remains unclear. The Enterprise Chamber explicitly takes the extent of the information already available into account.
The ruling also shows that the Enterprise Chamber interprets the question of jurisdiction broadly: it considers itself competent to order a provisional taking of evidence in preparation for a request for withdrawal or an inquiry, even though Article 66 of the Rules of Procedure is silent on this point.
What you can do
As a shareholder, do you wish to initiate a preliminary witness examination as a first step towards a withdrawal or inquiry procedure? If so, the preparation of the application is crucial. We would be happy to advise you on the evidential position: what information do you already have, what is demonstrably missing, and what would a witness examination yield that you cannot obtain by other means? We also examine the timing and procedural structure – the rejection of the conditional inquiry request in this case demonstrates that a late expansion of the request can quickly contravene the proper conduct of proceedings.
Would you like more information?
Please contact Michiel or one of the other professionals from the Corporate & Commercial Litigation.