Back to news overview

Corporate & Commercial Litigation

Bankruptcy as a weapon in a battle for funds: the Court of Appeal draws a line

10 September 2026

A petition for bankruptcy backed by a judgment declared provisionally enforceable would seem to be a strong trump card. Nevertheless, the Amsterdam Court of Appeal dismissed this petition — on the grounds that the context in which it was filed rendered the remedy disproportionate.

The case

A limited partnership (CV) established in 2003 as an investment fund for commercial premises in Leiden ran into serious difficulties. In 2014, the fund manager was replaced, new profit-sharing agreements were made without the consent of the silent partners, and the bank threatened to call in the loan. In February 2022, the property was sold at a profit. The proceeds were distributed in accordance with the agreements made in 2014. This subsequently led to discontent amongst the unitholders regarding the distribution.

In August 2022, the unitholders set up a new company to act as the managing partner of the CV. A meeting of participants approved this appointment by a large majority. The original managing partner (which was by then in liquidation) contested this. In proceedings before the District Court of The Hague, the judge ruled in an interim judgment of 24 December 2025 that the limited partnership had not been validly dissolved and that the new managing partner had not been lawfully appointed; the replacement of the managing partner required the consent of all partners.

In the final judgement of 6 May 2026, declared provisionally enforceable, the District Court of The Hague ordered the new managing partner to repay €244,853.31 (principal sum) to the original managing partner. The new managing partner, acting in that capacity for the limited partnership, had caused that amount to be paid out from the Fund. The new managing partner lodged an appeal.

Subsequently, on 22 May 2026, the original managing partner and the limited partnership filed an application with the Amsterdam District Court for the new managing partner to be declared bankrupt. The Amsterdam District Court dismissed this application on 3 July 2026: the existence of claims for support and the state of insolvency had not been established on a summary basis. The appellants lodged an appeal with the Amsterdam Court of Appeal.

The legal issue

Section 6(3) of the Bankruptcy Act (Fw) provides that a declaration of bankruptcy shall be made if it appears, on a summary basis, from facts and circumstances that the debtor has ceased to pay, and — in the case of an application by a creditor -- also of that creditor’s right to claim. This requirement of ‘prima facie evidence’ involves a low standard of proof: a swift, general assessment without an extensive examination of the facts.

Two main questions arose in this appeal. The first: could the required plurality of creditors be demonstrated in addition to the recognised claim of €244,853.31? The second: was the petition for bankruptcy, filed whilst several proceedings on the merits between the same parties were still pending, an abuse of rights within the meaning of Article 3:13 of the Dutch Civil Code?

The ruling

The Court of Appeal did not dispute that the appellants had a claim due and payable against the new managing partner on the basis of the judgment of 6 May 2026. However, the second requirement of a plurality of creditors was not summarily established.

The appellants argued that participants had granted a total of 44 loans to finance legal proceedings, amounting to a combined total of €158,500. However, those loans had been contractually entered into with the limited partnership as the borrower, not with the new managing partner. The Court of Appeal ruled that, in light of the ongoing dispute, it could not be assessed with sufficient certainty whether those loans had in fact given rise to claims against the new managing partner. This depends on what the borrowed money was spent on and what the contracting parties had agreed in this regard. This could not be ascertained in insolvency proceedings.

The same applied to the other ancillary claims put forward by the appellants. The alleged claim arising from unlawful attachments failed due to the requirement for a final and binding judgment: according to established case law of the Supreme Court (ECLI:NL:HR:2006:AV1559), the unlawfulness of an attachment is only established once there is a final and binding judicial ruling on the non-existence of the right of claim on which the attachment was based. This was lacking — the appeal against the judgment of 6 May 2026 was still pending. Nor could the claim alleged on the grounds of improper administration be established on a summary basis, since that liability had not previously been raised and the fundamental question of the lawfulness of the appointment itself was still before the court.

Consequently, the existence of multiple creditors had not been established on a summary basis.

The Court of Appeal added an independent, decisive consideration to this. The application for bankruptcy took place against the backdrop of a major dispute concerning the winding up of the Fund, in which a large number of individuals and legal entities were involved in various proceedings. There was no evidence of external creditors — creditors who were not involved in the dispute over the distribution of the Fund’s assets. In those circumstances, the Court of Appeal characterised the filing of the bankruptcy petition as a disproportionate measure: the bankruptcy would complicate the ongoing proceedings concerning the lawfulness of the distribution of the Fund and thereby unduly prejudice the interests of the other party. The appellants should reasonably have refrained from making the application.

The Court of Appeal upheld the order of the Amsterdam District Court of 3 July 2026 and ordered the appellants to pay the costs of the appeal (€3,431).

Implications for practice

This judgment demonstrates that a judgment declared provisionally enforceable is not, by definition, sufficient as a basis for a petition for bankruptcy. There are two distinct stumbling blocks.

The first is the requirement for plurality. In a complex structure – a fund with dozens of participants, multiple companies and overlapping legal claims – proving the existence of supporting claims is far from straightforward. Claims raised internally must be contractually demonstrable as resting with the debtor in question. The mere fact that a sum has passed through an entity is not sufficient for this purpose.

The second is the proportionality test. Even if all the formal requirements of Section 6 of the Insolvency Act are met, the court may reject the application if the insolvency proceedings constitute a disproportionate measure. This test is particularly relevant where the creditor and the debtor are already engaged in proceedings on the merits that are being hindered by bankruptcy, and there are no independent external creditors. In such cases, bankruptcy ceases to be a collective means of recovery and, in the court’s view, becomes merely a means of exerting pressure.

What you can do

If you find yourself in a situation where a bankruptcy petition is on the table – whether as the applicant or the respondent – it is advisable to assess in advance whether all the requirements of Article 6 of the Bankruptcy Act can be met and whether the petition will pass the proportionality test. This requires a thorough analysis of the evidence relating to the claims for support and of the broader procedural context.

TeekensKarstens is happy to assist with the strategic considerations surrounding bankruptcy petitions in complex disputes, including the preparation of the petition or the defence against it.

Would you like more information?

Please contact Michiel or one of the other professionals from the Corporate & Commercial Litigation.